Thursday, November 19, 2026

“When a Document is Official” by Frederic Remington

 


He was a light man, trim in his figure, quiet in manner, serious in mind. His nose, eyes, and mouth denoted strong character, and also that there had been little laughter in his life. He had a mustache, and beyond this nothing can be said, because cavalrymen are primitive men, weighing no more than one hundred and sixty pounds. The horse is responsible for this, because he cannot carry more, and that weight even then must be pretty much on the same ancient lines. You never see long, short, or odd curves on top of a cavalry horse--not with nine years of field service.

This story from legendary artist of the west Mr. Remington, first appeared in Harper’s Magazine in 1899 and was added to the collection Men With the Bark On in 1900.

This story is good fortune for all connoisseurs of the legitimate west as here we have not only a Man who Lived in the Times, who Met and Mingled with the Reality, but we also have a Master Artisan, an observer of the first order.

Remington’s words add judgment to the romantic lines of his paintings and sculptures. This story gives us his opinion of that which he limned so well in the visual medium.

A brief story, but one so full of realistic gusto it punches well above its page count.

One last bit from Mr. Remington.

Men with bark on do not say things in their lighter moods that go for much; but when these were behind a sage-brush handling a Sharps, or skimming among the tailing buffaloes on a strong pony, what grunts were got out of them had meaning!

Monday, November 9, 2026

The Leatherstocking Saga by James Fenimore Cooper, Edited by Allan Nevins

 


Actually, the full title is…

Being those parts of The Deerslayer, The Last of the Mohicans, The Pathfinder, The Pioneers, and The Prairie which specially pertain to Natty Bumppo otherwise known as Pathfinder, Deerslayer, or Hawkeye; the whole arranged in chronological order from Hawkeye’s youth on the New York frontier in King George's war until his death on the Western prairies in Jefferson’s Administration.

No one who is conversant with the Western genre or frontier fiction, let alone American literature is not at the very least familiar with the name of Fenimore Cooper, or The Last of the Mohicans. Fewer have read the most famous volume let alone the entire quartet of novels.

Those who have, must admit that some of it is a slog. But there are also moments of high brilliance, sparks of poetry, suffused with romance and a true love of the land.

What we have here is a gift from the editor Allan Nevins. He has taken all five novels, rearranged them into one epic novel and trimmed much of what felt a slog.

In short, it is the Cooper high spots read as a narrative whole.

Today we may underestimate just how influential and popular Cooper was on both the American continent and across the pond. English authors such as William Makepeace Thackeray held him higher in esteem than his own beloved Isle’s Walter Scott; French heads of state quoted from the novels well into WWI.

The luster fell off Cooper sometime in the early 20th Century. Nevins sought to restore the sheen to these novels that were held in such esteem.

Here is Nevins from his Introduction.

The proper course in reading Cooper (as with Scott, Hugo and many another) is to cast side all his inferior works; to fasten on the best books; to practice judicious skipping; and to dwell judiciously on elements of strength. When this is done, Cooper stands forth as a great writer. Some of his heroines are women as staunch, true, and fearless as any American life ever produced. His descriptions, harder to detach from the structure of his novels than careless readers suppose, sometimes rank with the best word painting; for they are filled, as Bryant noted, with a true poetry. Many of the quaint utterances of Leatherstocking and Tom Coffin go straight to the heart of knotty human problems as their balls [bullets] went to their targets. Most of the dialogue is simplicity and naturalness itself. And the cumulative effect of the Leatherstocking tales, like that of Scott's stories of his native land, is tremendous. Those who take the pains to read the five novels attentively, taking them in proper succession from Deerslayer's awkward youth to the trapper’s mellow old age, will find that they have read nothing less than the nearest approach yet made to an American epic.

Nevins has done us a great service in providing a condensed single-volume that returns this volume to its proper stature.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

“On Historical Fiction” by Arnold J Toynbee

 


What is it that we are looking for in other people's lives when we find ourselves wanting to read about them in histories or biographies or novels? If other people's experiences are to hold our attention, they must excite our curiosity; and, for that, they must be different enough from our own experiences to be interesting, but not so different as to be incomprehensible.

This is an unusual offering. It is the introduction to a 1954 book of historical fiction about the Viking Age titled The Foster Brothers by Edward Frankland [retitled The Long Swords in 1956.]

The untitled introduction is by legendary historian Arthur Toynbee, author of the still interesting 12-volume A Study of History.

Here, the noted historian makes the case for historical fiction [and he does cover the Western in his definition] as being of prime value for the student of history. He goes beyond that commendation to say that we as human beings can become more temporally linked to our forebears by the skillful humanization of former eras.

More from Toynbee.

Here we have our fellow men and women of the Heroic Age painted for us in their true colors. But, granting that this picture does arouse our curiosity, why, one might ask, should one go to find it in a work of fiction but why not go to some historian’s reconstruction of life in the Heroic Age from the original literature that the Heroic Age has bequeathed to us? The answer lies in the nature of historical records, for these often fail to tell us directly just the things that we most want to know, especially the most intimate things about personal relations and experiences. That is why the people of this Historic Age, who were infant prodigies as well as juvenile delinquents, chose to immortalize themselves, not in blue books or white papers, but in epics and sagas in which historical facts have been transmuted into fiction, as Vandal smiths used to meltdown Roman coins and forged the gold into torques and bracelets for the embellishment of disreputable barbarian warriors.

Here, he sounds almost wistful at the tools the fictioneer can command as opposed to his bounded set.

This freedom to recreate the landscape of a past age, and to people it with intimate personal life, the author has resources which are not at a historian's command; and we need all the resources that can be offered to us if we are to enter imaginatively into the lives of other men and women in other times and places. This is always worth doing, because our common humanity involves us in the lives of all our fellow human beings who have ever lived. The Roman playwright Terence makes one of his characters say: “As a human being, I am a party to every jot of human experience.” This is surely a saying which we should all take to heart.

I, as an avid historical fiction reader found this introduction illuminating and perhaps revelatory as to the “why” of my tastes. As an author, it strikes me that the historical novelist may find this outside view from Toynbee heartening and inspiring and perhaps a spur to better work.

Monday, October 19, 2026

“Flashing Spikes” by Frank O’Rourke

 


“I caught that one,” I said.

“Good hit,” he said evenly. “How'd you guess it?”

“He wiggled his glove,” I said. “I watched him three innings. He does that when he throws that slow hook.”

“Good eyes,” he said, moving back to position.

I felt pretty cocky and took my lead and the pitcher turned, off the rubber, and grinned at me; and then the big man moved with deceptive speed, cutting in behind me, took the underhand flip from the second baseman and tagged me out by five feet.

“Watch the ball,” he said tonelessly. “Don't start no jaw-act when you're feeling so good.”

This is the titular story from O’Rourke’s 1948 collection of sports stories. I offer this baseball story so we can have a look at a master of the Western genre operating in another area of expertise, the sports story.

All the skill and inside knowledge is there.

This tale of redemption has the earmarks of the young gunfighter receiving hard-won wisdom from the Old Hand.

It is told in O’Rourke’s trademark terse laconic informed style.

I am, admittedly, not a baseball guy, yet still enjoyed O’Rourke’s take.

It seems no matter the genre, his mature humanity is ever-present.

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

“Ride the Red Killer” by N.E. Snoke

 


The universe belonged to Red Hellion and me! And I was going to conquer… I wasn't going to set back and die from inaction and boredom! Excitement—action—speed! Any damn thing to keep from thinking!

This story appeared in the September 1952 issue of Dime Western magazine.

Here we have a post-World War II tale of a former rodeo rider who lost a hand in combat. We travel inside our protagonist’s head as he navigates the waters of recovery, bitterness, and re-claiming the whole man inside as he comes to grip with this new lot in life.

It is a brief tale, but one of maturity. There are no shoot-em-up heroics; just a man with an obstacle to surmount and the complicated issues of the soul that go along with a man who chooses not to lay down no matter what is handed to him.

A bonafide buried treasure of mature Western writing from an author I was unfamiliar with and as far as I can tell his only printed piece.

Tuesday, September 8, 2026

“Fruit Tramp” by Daniel Mainwaring

 


[A Labor Day week offering.]

Still the fruit tramps came every year when the Elbertas were turning yellow in the shiny leaves. Not so many came, but the grove was pretty well filled with men and women and children who drove along the highway leading to the hills and pitched their camps in the shade of the trees planted there by a man named Cole fifty years before.

When times were bad it wasn't easy to make a living picking peaches and grapes, cutting the peaches in half, laying them in orderly rows on the trays. It was hard, unpleasant work. Out in the orchards the heat waves rose, and when you knelt on the earth to pick the fruit up the sand burned through your overalls. The cutting sheds offered little shelter from the sun, and the fuzz from the peaches crept up the women's arms and down the necks of their dresses. They stood all day on the packed earth of the shed, picking the fruit up with their nimble fingers, jabbing the knife point to the soft flesh and, with a twist, halving the fruit.

This 1934 short story by Daniel Mainwaring is an example of the proletarian fiction that was popular in the Depression era, the most notable example being Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath.

This genre emphasized the plight of the common man, often had a political bent to it, and when in an urban setting, there was often a strong union element to it.

Alternately, when proletarian fiction had a rural setting as in the case of the itinerant fruit pickers in this story or the melon industry in Elmore Leonard’s Mr. Majestyk, the tales take on a decidedly gritty western feel. We are treated to accurate descriptions of hard work and when there is confrontation,as in this story and Mr. Majestyk, one is hard-pressed to deny that these are “Western Stories” in their own right.

[The Leonard novel is also reviewed on in this blog]

Mainwaring’s story, found in the July 1934 issue of Harper’s Magazine is a strong example of the proletarian genre with an obvious element of the Western to it.

In addition, it is a fine piece of writing well in the vein of the aforementioned Mr. Leonard.

Well worth a read.

Wednesday, August 26, 2026

Jade: Outlaw by Robert Flynn

 


He didn’t take a bottle but stopped at the half-shack, half-tent saloon, walked across the dirt floor, asked for a beer and took it to the end of the short and dusty bar that was under the wooden roof. Shep, in for his two beers before bed, spoke to him. Two pistoleros nodded. Jade nodded but didn’t invite conversation. Jade was drinking his beer when a woman joined him. “New to town, ain’t you? Thought we might get acquainted.” She tried to look bright but looked over-handled despite her youth, and her eyes were dull with knowledge of men. Jade had calico fever but the misery in her face was twin to his own and he didn’t want to know more of it.

A beautifully written brief novel of the confusion of hatred, desire, duty, shame, doubt, remorse and sundry other adult themes.

Our protagonist, not written to be admired but he still is by others although he does not admire himself is moved to conflict by his fascination with a woman who was a former Indian captive.

“It’s done,” he said, and watched as she cut her steak and ate biscuits and gravy. She had a healthy appetite but didn’t talk with her mouth full or chew with her mouth open. She cooked regular fare and there was plenty of it. She had enough sand for two brooms. Strong enough to carry her side of the teepee in both ways. But she was Indian. Not by birth but by choice. She looked Indian--dark eyes, long, straight black hair. He didn’t know that he could abide that. But her dark eyes were really brown with green flecks, hair so black it sometimes had a blue sheen. Her lips were even, neither thin nor blown, but with small lines above her upper lip. From chewing leather to soften it?

“What did you like about being Indian?” he asked, believing that no decent white woman could.

“Family. Boys competed to be the fastest, the strongest, best with a horse, best with a bow, with a lance but it was for the tribe not just personal glory. Listening to the stories and making our own stories. Girls worked beside their mothers who showed us how to gather roots, nuts, berries, firewood, buffalo chips, finding and cooking with a new herb, sewing skins to make a teepee, smoking meat, making moccasins to please our husbands who fed and protected the village. I loved following my mother, playing at cooking, washing, making and taking down teepees.

“Every girl had a doll and learned to make clothing for it. Sometimes girls worked and sang together cleaning and softening hides. When the village moved we helped our mothers take down the teepee and helped them move the poles, the hides to wherever we went. When our fathers had no horses to spare we carried everything. “When one died, all grieved. No one owned the land, or the river, or the sky. There was no glory in owning. It would be dishonorable to ride one horse and lead one if another brave was afoot. If you had two robes and someone was cold, you gave them one. Not to do so would be disgraceful. When one triumphed all celebrated. Here, smaller than an Indian village, they allow brutality to neighbors.”

Jade remains puzzled, confused, repelled by the woman who embraces what he loathes.

The novel, while not action heavy, reveals enough pragmatic scoutcraft to let us know this author and character knows what’s what.

They didn’t ride like Indians but one had a star or concho that glittered when the sun hit it. Or a gold watch hanging from his shirt. Why would someone wear glitter in Indian country? Jade wondered. Might as well hold the arrow to your breast and ask a brave to let go of the bow string.

The stark lyricism of the prose is not confined to our protagonists, all characters have a sense of desolation to them.

“Hannah believed I would fulfill her dreams but instead she fell victim to mine.”

While not a classic, this mature novel is well worth a read for the discerning.

“Have you ever seen the sea?” she asked him.

“No.”

“They tell me it tastes of salt.”

“I’ve heard that,” Jade agreed “Rain is not salty. Tears are salty. The sea must be the collected tears of people.”

“I have heard that beneath the ground is a great fire and it breaks through sometimes,” Jade said. “I have seen where the fire has broken through. Maybe tears are what keeps it from burning up the earth.”

“When a Document is Official” by Frederic Remington

  He was a light man, trim in his figure, quiet in manner, serious in mind. His nose, eyes, and mouth denoted strong character, and also tha...